TV-PGJune 16, 2004: Apple's reported song count for Euro iTMS isn't all its cracked up to be; maybe if the indie labels weren't holding out for variable pricing things would be a bit different. Meanwhile, a leaked ad confirms the rumored BMW-iPod integration project, and when the questions get tough, Steve calls in the muscle...
But First, A Word From Our Sponsors
 

From the writer/creator of AtAT, a Pandemic Dad Joke taken WAYYYYYY too far

 
How Many & How Come (6/16/04)
SceneLink
 

Mystery solved! You know how yesterday we were a little suspicious of Apple's claim that the new European iTunes Music Stores had a catalog of 700,000 songs? Our impression from browsing through the stores' libraries was that the airline must have lost half of Apple's luggage on the flight over, since plenty of artists were listed with no songs available. While we've since heard from a few viewers that the stores' selection of local music was quite good, the overwhelming sentiment expressed among the European AtAT viewership is that there are indeed gaping holes in the Euro iTMS catalog, and they're not just from the missing music from the indie labels who pulled out at the last minute. So here, then, is the question: if there are 700,000 songs available, just where the heck are they?

Answer: a lot of them are precisely where you're not. The Mac Observer got to the bottom of this riddle wrapped in a mystery inside a toasted enigma topped with four kinds of cheese with a pickle on the side, and apparently when Apple said that Euro iTMS had 700,000 songs, it meant collectively. In other words, toss the catalogs from the French, German, and UK stores into a giant blender, hit "liquefy," and you wind up with a lovely 700,000-song smoothie to chug. The problem is that the stores don't share content that way, and between the local music available only to each store and the wacky per-country licensing of internationally-available songs, Apple reportedly confirmed to analysts that each store on its own only has "300,000 to 400,000" songs apiece.

Of course, now the mystery is why that TMO article has seemingly vanished without a trace; you can still see a link to the original piece on yesterday's MacSurfer page, complete with the title "TMO Reports - 700,000 iTMS Cuts in UK? More Like 300-400K, Analysts Told," but the link is dead; we have a feeling that perhaps those analysts weren't supposed to have blabbed what Apple had told them, and the article got yoinked. But it's not a big deal; in any case, most users agree that the Euro iTMS feels a little empty and Needs More Stuff™. And since the missing indie music certainly qualifies as More Stuff™, it's nice that The Mac Observer has another article (which was still available when last we checked) with details about why the indie labels refused to sign.

Reportedly it all comes down to length of commitment: Apple wanted a three-year license at a set fee, which the indies called "commercial suicide" because the whole downloadable music business is so new. The Association of Independent Music notes that the iTMS plays in a "constantly changing market" and that demand could accommodate higher prices down the road, so it was insisting on a "universal price review after six or twelve months." In other words, if things go well, the indies want the right to raise their price to Apple, which would in turn cause song prices at, say, the UK iTMS to jump come January. The indies were also pushing for "an adjustable royalty price that would go up as the retail price goes up"-- so if a given label raises its CD prices, its iTMS tracks would also get more expensive. Apparently "Apple was unwilling to discuss such a clause."

Now, we're all for indie music, folks. In fact, we hardly bought anything at the iTMS until the indies started climbing on board-- just this morning we bought an album by Big Collapse. But don't these demands sound eerily familiar? Isn't this, broadly speaking, the same sort of stuff that the major labels have been angling for, only slightly less evil? We had originally suspected that Apple was throwing its weight around as the top download service and trying to squeeze shockingly unfair deals from the indies, as market-leading corporations are sadly wont to do. But it sounds to us like Apple is mostly concerned with keeping prices at the iTMS low and consistent, something they've fought hard to do here in the States. Remember, the majors have been pushing for pricing based on popularity, with the "hottest songs" rising to as high as $2.49; Apple has so far managed to prevent that from happening, and we, for one, are glad of it.

Then again, there's still the fact that iTunes is the only download service with which the indies haven't yet inked European agreements, which implies that Apple is being somehow less fair. But given that Napster, Sony, OD2, etc. all see themselves as the Davids who have to fell the iTMS Goliath, is it any wonder that they'd ink deals perhaps a little less protective of the consumer buying process just to get their hands on the content? We certainly don't mean to imply that Apple's being an angel in all of this, but we have to respect its apparent goal of keeping prices at a uniform and consumer-friendly level for the next few years-- even though we also respect the indies' desire to keep a tighter control on how much money they get for their music. Here's hoping someone discovers a patch of acceptable middle ground, and soon.

Meanwhile, the battle rages on. But as for you Euro iTMS customers disappointed with the current dearth of cool tunes to buy, don't despair; the U.S. store felt pretty empty when it launched, as well. Remember, we only had 200,000 songs available back then, and no indie content whatsoever; now there's a half a million more songs and buckets more being added every week. Give it a little time. Apple and the indies will reach an agreement, the majors will eventually grant some sort of Europe-wide license, and before too long you'll be going broke at an alarming pace. See? There's always a bright side.

 
SceneLink (4760)
Baby You Can Drive My Car (6/16/04)
SceneLink
 

If you're the obsessive type (and really, who isn't these days?), your feverish brain may well have fixated on a quick little infonugget that popped out during Steve Jobs's appearance at the D: All Things Digital conference last week-- namely, that Apple is working on some sort of iPod-to-car interface. And just in case you figured that someone had merely heard him wrong, Steve mentioned the device again during the London Music Event yesterday, saying that it should be coming along later this year. But what manner of device might it be? That's what ought to poke through your grey matter and rattle around a bit.

Really, as far as obsessions go, it's not a bad topic to chew up your excess brain cycles, because so far most of the existing methods of listening to an iPod in the car leave something to be desired. If you have a cassette player in your car stereo, there's always the trusty ol' cassette adapter, but they can produce an annoying background whirring noise to accompany your music, and some people insist that the sound reproduction isn't the greatest, either. If you've got an FM radio, you can get one of those tuner thingies like the iTrip, but if you live in an urban area you might have a tough time finding a frequency empty enough for decent sound. (We had really bad luck in both Boston and Chicago.) Even if you're lucky enough to have an 1/8" line-in jack in your dashboard, you still need to select and control your music on the iPod itself-- which can be cumbersome, especially when your car might have a CD player that's wired into a nice big color LCD in the dash and nifty control buttons right in the steering wheel. Clearly the automotive iPod experience has room for improvement.

Well, the good news is that if you had any doubt left, you can now rest assured that Apple is, indeed, working on it-- for some of us, anyway. Faithful viewer Andrew Galbraith tipped us off to a MacMinute "exclusive" describing an upcoming "two-page joint advertisement from Apple and BMW for a new iPod car adapter"; it says "Control freaks, rejoice" and touts "the first seamless integration of iPod and automobile." Reportedly the system-- whatever it is-- will be available first for the BMW 3 Series, X3, and Z4, and when it's installed, it'll allow control of the iPod "through the existing audio system and multi-function steering wheel." And there's a URL in the ad: iPodYourBMW.com, which currently just points to a generic "Coming Soon!" page.

Now, while it's true that many of these details were available at AppleInsider a day earlier, MacMinute went so far as to pony up some scans; pity they don't show the device itself, or what sort of interface you get through the BMW's audio system. And it's also a bit of a bummer that, at least so far, you'll need at least a $28,000 car for this level of iPod integration. But it's a start, and while details are scarce, it sounds like it's at least marginally better than our own iPod-in-the-car solution, which consists of a pair of Cambridge Soundworks Newton T300 Tower Speakers, a Marantz PM-7000 Integrated Amplifier, four stout bungee cords, and a Really Long Extension Cord™. (Patent pending, of course.)

 
SceneLink (4761)
Sideburns & White Jumpsuit (6/16/04)
SceneLink
 

While the Apple world cools down following yesterday's big London announcement, we thought we'd take a moment amid the silence to take another look at Steve's trip to the UK. As you may be aware, public appearances in England are rare for Steve, not least because when he does deign to speak there for a conference or whatever, he has a history of canceling to go keynote somewhere else instead. But while there was no webcast, we've seen photographic proof that Steve really did show up to do the honors at Old Billingsgate Market, which is, if anything, bigger news than Euro iTMS itself. Here's hoping that the Brits appreciated that they were being graced with the presence of a real live rock star yesterday-- and no, we're not talking about Alicia Keys.

Whaddaya mean, Steve's not a rock star? Of course he is. Just because he doesn't actually produce any music certainly doesn't disqualify him, at least judging by what we hear whenever we accidentally turn on the radio. (Yes, we're officially old now. We're at peace with that.) Besides, if you want proof of Steve's unquestionable rockstarness, you need look no further than BBC NewsNight, which broadcast a segment on the Euro iTMS launch and made it available, albeit temporarily, in RealVideo form. Caution: if you're used to something a little more like QuickTime, 34 Kbps RealVideo may trigger your gag reflex. Keep a bucket handy.

In fact, why don't we just make it easy? Faithful viewer Basil was kind enough to mention that the relevant bit starts at about 30:30, so you can minimize your exposure to some of the worst streaming video quality we've seen since the early prototypes that used two tin cans and a length of string and just scrub straight to the good stuff. For those of you unwilling to traumatize yourself in this fashion (or who missed the stream before it was replaced with the next show), here's what you're missing: Steve and Ms. Alicia Keys are posing for post-event photo ops, and the NewsNight reporter shouts out, "Steve, what's the future for Apple if all this doesn't work?" Steve grins and chuckles, pauses briefly, nods dismissively, turns away, and the reporter is immediately set upon by a bodyguard. Not Alicia's, mind you-- Steve's.

That's right, Steve slips out off to the side as a surly guy blocks the camera with his torso and says "he's not answering that one, as you know." And then we're back in the studio with the anchorman. Had the camera kept rolling just a few seconds longer, we've no doubt we would have heard an announcement that "ladies and gentlemen, Steve has left the building." What, no encore?

 
SceneLink (4762)
← Previous Episode
Next Episode →
Vote Early, Vote Often!
Why did you tune in to this '90s relic of a soap opera?
Nostalgia is the next best thing to feeling alive
My name is Rip Van Winkle and I just woke up; what did I miss?
I'm trying to pretend the last 20 years never happened
I mean, if it worked for Friends, why not?
I came here looking for a receptacle in which to place the cremated remains of my deceased Java applets (think about it)

(1287 votes)
Apple store at Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, AtAT earns from qualifying purchases

DISCLAIMER: AtAT was not a news site any more than Inside Edition was a "real" news show. We made Dawson's Creek look like 60 Minutes. We engaged in rampant guesswork, wild speculation, and pure fabrication for the entertainment of our viewers. Sure, everything here was "inspired by actual events," but so was Amityville II: The Possession. So lighten up.

Site best viewed with a sense of humor. AtAT is not responsible for lost or stolen articles. Keep hands inside car at all times. The drinking of beverages while watching AtAT is strongly discouraged; AtAT is not responsible for damage, discomfort, or staining caused by spit-takes or "nosers."

Everything you see here that isn't attributed to other parties is copyright ©,1997-2024 J. Miller and may not be reproduced or rebroadcast without his explicit consent (or possibly the express written consent of Major League Baseball, but we doubt it).